Do you expect fpgas to replace gpus for deep learning. Stratix 10 fpga outperforms the gpu when using pruned or compact data. Both fpga and gpu vendors offer a platform to process information from raw data in a fast and efficient manner. Fpga and gpubased acceleration of ml workloads on amazon. Fpga chips will be the hardware future for deep learning. Ai vs deep learning vs machine learning data science. Their goal was to demonstrate that opencl based implementations can be implemented efficiently on a fpga. Ive heard that titan x pascal from nvidia might be the most powerful gpu available at the moment, but would be interesting to learn about other options. Machine learning is widely used in many modern artificial intelligence applications. Randy huang, fpga architect, intel programmable solutions group, and one of the coauthors, states, deep learning is the most. London, july 18, 2017 prnewswire deep learning technology is driving the evolution of artificial intelligence ai and has become one of the hottest topics of discussion within the technology. Scale from workstation to supercomputer, with a 4x 2080ti workstation starting. Data analytics often rely on machine learning ml algorithms. The industry is accustomed to integration at the board level, according to rowen.
An example is the proof of work functions in cryptocurrency. Design space exploration of fpgabased deep convolutional neural networks, in. Classifies 50,000 validation set images at 500 imagessecond at 35 w. Each fpga accelerator and indeed, any gpu or dsp accelerator that. Performance comparison of gpu and fpga architectures for the svm training problem markos papadonikolakis 1, christossavvas bouganis 2, george constantinides 3 department of electrical and electronic engineering, imperial college london. Cheung imperial college london, electrical and electronic engineering, london abstractheterogeneous or coprocessor architectures are becoming an important component of high productivity computing systems hpcs. While in an earlier article we have compared the use of these two ai chips for autonomous car makers, in this article we would do a comparison for other dataintensive work such as deep learning. It seems power9 is targeted to be a better fit with gpufpgawhatever, and that sounds reasonable. I think for the majority of deep learning application developers, gpus are the best tool available. Performance comparison of gpu and fpga architectures for. Deephi tech is a fpga deep learning platform provider for drones, robotics, surveillance cameras and data center applications. What is the best gpu for deep learning currently available on the market.
The innovation has not stopped though, a very recent trend is the addition of tensor cores to further speed up the deep learning use cases. There is an intels article intel processors for deep learning training exploring the main factors contributing. Their research evaluates emerging dnn algorithms on two generations of intel fpgas intel arria10 and intel stratix 10 against the latest highest performance nvidia titan x pascal graphics processing unit gpu. There are three aspects important in fpga reconfiguration not programming 1 digital design 2 fpga specific matters 3 hdl language about 1, there are many good textbooks which you can find by searching digital circuit design in amazon. Finally, it makes key recommendations of future directions for fpga hardware acceleration that would help in. The main reason for that is the lower cost and lower power consumption of fpgas compared to gpus in deep learning applications. Deephi platforms are based on xilinx fpgas and socs, which provide the ideal combination of flexibility, high performance, low latency and low power consumption. Three of the most popular deep learning packages are theano, torch, and caffe. Deep learning as an evolved form of neural nets can be used to solve regular data science problems in the same way that neural net algorithms have always been used. To improve the performance and maintain the scalability, we present cnnlab, a novel deep learning framework using gpu and fpgabased accelerators. Gpus, fpgas, and hard choices in the cloud and onpremise. Many deep learning solutions were based on the use of gpus. The right answer, in many cases, is none of the above its an assp, rowen said.
We will select the most widely used open source software package that is used by the deep learning community and rewrite the kernels for a fieldprogrammable gate array fpga and compare it with other implementations gpu for energy efficiency study. Gpu vs fpga trends gpus have traditionally been used for dnns, due to the data parallel computations, which exhibit regular parallelism and require high floatingpoint computation throughput. Probably the same economics work in the data center too. It might be true that latency cant be improved much by using an offtheshelf fpga but performance in parallel processing tasks can. How can gpus and fpgas help with dataintensive tasks such as operations, analytics, and. Even though you can optimize inference for power and throughput in an fpga in many cases, the workflow still requires building the model in a highlevel framework, training and testing on a gpu, then taking the trained parameters and compressing. A good example is amazons current major investment in deep learning to create better recommenders that enhance shopping. Physically, fpgas and gpus often plug into a server pcie slot.
Deep learning binary neural network on an fpga by shrutika redkar a thesis submitted to the faculty of the worcester polytechnic institute in partial ful llment of the requirements for the degree of master of science in electrical and computer engineering by may 2017 approved. This is the process we call learning and memories are believed to be held in the trillions of synaptic connections. If gpu is used for nongraphical processing, they are termed as gpgpus general purpose graphics processing unit. Deep learning technology as it pertains to chipsets is very technical and tractica explains the various approaches different vendors are taking to solve the problem and the tradeoffs involved. Fpgabased accelerators of deep learning networks for. Timeline of important events in fpga deep learning research. Each generation of gpu has incorporated more floatingpoint units, onchip rams, and higher memory bandwidth, in order to offer increased flops. Can fpgas beat gpus in accelerating nextgeneration deep.
There is no special case for fpga replacing gpu for deep learning. While gpus are wellpositioned in machine learning, data type flexibility and power efficiency are making fpgas increasingly attractive. Looking further to the future, hu explained that inspur will develop fpgabased system. March 21, 2017 linda barney ai, compute 15 continued exponential growth of digital data of images, videos, and speech from sources such as social media and the internetofthings is driving the need for analytics to make that data understandable and actionable. Digital design for beginners with mojo and lucid hdl. This delivers endtoend application performance that is significantly greater than a fixedarchitecture ai accelerator like a gpu. It helps to understand that the gpu is valuable because it accelerates the tensor math processing necessary for deep learning applications. Ive tried training the same model with the same data on cpu of my macbook pro 2. Why are gpus necessary for training deep learning models. The ability of fpga to be programmable and less power consumption makes it another brilliant choice while typical gpu has its own graphics pipeline sets which has its own bottleneck. Quantifies a confidence level via 1,000 outputs for each classified image. Here i will quickly give a few knowhows before you go on to buy a gpu. To tackle these problems, we present a scalable deep learning accelerator unit named dlau to speed up the kernel computational parts of deep learning algorithms.
Emerging universal fpga, gpu platform for deep learning. From a systems design perspective, the modern fpga is an entirely different beast than gpu, though its possible to apply either one for similar tasks in. Gpu versus fpga for high productivity computing david h. Jones, adam powell, christossavvas bouganis, peter y. On the cpu and gpu, we utilize standard libraries on. However, there is a lack of infrastructure available for deep learning on fpgas compared to what is available for gpps and gpus, and the practical challenges of developing such infrastructure are often ignored in contemporary work. Both xilinx and intel are touting the prowess of fpgas as accelerators for convolutional neural network cnn deep learning applications. These tasks and mainly graphics computations, and so gpu is graphics processing unit. Gpu, cpu, storage and more whether you work in nlp, computer vision, deep rl, or an allpurpose deep learning system. Since the popularity of using machine learning algorithms to extract and process the information from raw data, it has been. They quickly migrated to fpga as the energy cost of cpugpu was prohibitive. Researchers hope deep learning algorithms can run on fpgas.
Those neurons also change how they connect with each other in response to changing images, sounds, and the like. Researchers hope deep learning algorithms can run on fpgas and supercomputers. These ai applications typically have both training and inference phases. The fpga is of interest in finding a way to research new ai algorithms, train those systems, and to begin to deploy low volume. Blas comparison on fpga, cpu and gpu microsoft research. N can fpgas beat gpus in accelerating nextgeneration. Comparison of fpga, cpu, gpu, and asic, authornurvitadhi, eriko and sheffield, david and sim, jaewoong and mishra, asit and venkatesh, ganesh and marr, debbie. Exxact deep learning nvidia gpu solutions make the most of your data with deep learning.
It is used as an asicasicthe emergence of a semicustom circuit in the field not only solves the shortcomings of the custom circuit, but also overcomes the shortcomings of the limited. Until recently, most deep learning solutions were based on the use of gpus. In many applications, neural network is trained in backend. Cnn implementation using an fpga and opencl device. Professor xinming huang, major thesis advisor professor yehia massoud.
A hybrid gpufpgabased computing platform for machine learning. Machine learning hardware fpgas, gpus, cuda towards data. Next, it outlines the current state of fpga support for deep learning, identifying potential limitations. View all books view all videos view all learning paths view all technologies web development programming. Cnnlab provides a uniform programming model to users so that the hardware implementation and the scheduling are invisible to the programmers. To learn more about using cuda visit nvidias developer blog or check out the book cuda by example. Fpgas challenge gpus as a platform for deep learning so what is this lively debate all about. Emerging universal fpga, gpu platform for deep learning june 29, 2016 nicole hemsoth ai 3 in the last couple of years, we have written and heard about the usefulness of gpus for deep learning training as well as, to a lesser extent, custom asics and fpgas. The last fpga 2017 acm international symposium on fieldprogrammable gate arrays fpga event that took place in monterey, california us featured an important presentation about a chip development that may well be the future hardware stateoftheart for deep learning implementations. While its possible to be faster than an fpga with high core count, its probably not economical energy wise. Digital design for beginners with mojo and lucid hdl rajewski, justin on.
High performance computing hpc or scientific codes are being executed across a wide variety of computing platforms from embedded processors to massively parallel gpus. It is a deep learning application using inspurs fpgabased heterogeneous design of architecture and software developed in a highlevel programming model in opencl to enable migration from cpu to fpgas. Fpga fieldprogrammable gate array, which is a fieldprogrammable gate array, which is a product of further development based on programmable devices such as pal, gal, and cpld. We present a comparison of the basic linear algebra subroutines blas using doubleprecision floating point on an fpga, cpu and gpu. Cpu vs gpu for deep learning less than 1 minute read if anyone is wondering why would you need to use aws for machine learning after reading this post, heres a real example. Which are better for machine learning applications. Hardware accelerator design for machine learning intechopen. This paper explores the challenges of deep learning training and inference, and discusses the benefits of a comprehensive approach for combining cpu, gpu, fpga technologies, along with the appropriate software frameworks in a unified deep learning architecture.
236 912 294 710 353 599 26 1166 900 1068 1192 1354 1534 1182 383 360 1459 1375 1292 209 447 75 1181 351 218 1464 1445 241 1285 1027 724 361